Home / Chargebacks in Canada
Chargebacks in Canada: what a lost dispute costs
What a lost chargeback on a CA$60 sale costs at Helcim or Shopify
CA$75.00 is the sale plus a CA$15.00 fee. At Stripe it is CA$90.00 if you respond and lose, at Moneris CA$85.00 before a CA$80.00 handling fee it does not explain, and at Square CA$60.00, which prints no dispute fee. Helcim and Moneris print "$" without naming the currency; we read them as Canadian dollars.
How we test ยท How we are paid: no link on this page earns us money; the Merchant-Accounts.ca row is explained in the notes below.
What each provider charges
Fees only, plus the sale when you lose. "Win" means you responded with evidence and the card issuer decided for you. Goods, shipping and your time are not counted.
| Provider | Fee if you lose | Fee if you win | A lost CA$60.00 sale | What its page says |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Helcim | CA$15.00 | No fee | CA$75.00 | Free if resolved in your favour |
| Shopify Payments | CA$15.00 | No fee | CA$75.00 | Withdrawn at once, returned if you win |
| Stripe | CA$30.00 | CA$15.00 | CA$90.00 | Received fee stays; the countered fee comes back only on a win |
| Moneris | CA$25.00 | Not stated | CA$85.00 | Refund on a win not stated |
| Merchant-Accounts.ca | CA$20.00 | Not stated | CA$80.00 | Refund on a win not stated |
| Square | No fee | No fee | CA$60.00 | No dispute-management fee on disputes you challenge with Square; processing fees are not returned on a loss |
Prices read on each provider's own page on Nov 17, 2026, and Merchant-Accounts.ca's reader-rate page on Nov 18, 2026. Merchant-Accounts.ca may pay us if you sign up through the link on our card processing page; its row here is not ranked. Stripe prints CA$; Merchant-Accounts.ca, Moneris and Helcim print "$" and Shopify "$15 CAD or $15 USD" for Canada, so those are shown as printed. Stripe's CA$30.00 is the received fee plus the countered fee, which comes back only on a win; Moneris also lists an Authorization Chargeback Handling fee of CA$80.00 and does not say when it applies; if it applied as well, a lost CA$60.00 sale at Moneris would cost CA$165.00. Square says there are no fees for dispute management on chargebacks it helps you challenge, holds the disputed funds at once and does not refund processing fees on a loss. Processing fees on the sale itself are not in any total.
Fight it or accept it
At Stripe, accepting a CA$60.00 dispute costs the sale and the CA$15.00 received fee. Responding adds the CA$15.00 countered fee if you lose and recovers the sale if you win, so responding is cheaper once your chance of winning passes 20%. That is our sum from its fees, not Stripe's advice.
Stripe's Smart Disputes charges 30% of the disputed amount only when it wins, which is CA$18.00 on a won CA$60.00 sale. Responding yourself costs nothing extra on a win, so on fees alone it is cheaper once you expect to win more than 45.5% of the time. That assumes the same chance of winning either way, and that Smart Disputes carries no countered fee, which its pricing page does not say (it says only that the received fee still applies). Smart Disputes covers eligible disputes only, and if it raises your odds the sum changes. At Helcim and Shopify responding adds no fee, because the fee is waived or returned on a win.
The clocks
| Where | The clock |
|---|---|
| Square | Seven days to respond, with the funds held at once |
| Stripe and Shopify | Usually 7 to 21 days to respond |
| Shopify's review | Up to 75 days after you submit |
| Card networks, per Mastercard's article | Typically 20 to 45 days after you are notified, and acquirers average 10 to 35. The article is not Canada-specific. |
| Mastercard, in total | Up to 120 days |
| Your customer | Networks typically allow 120 days to open a dispute (Stripe's docs) |
Miss your processor's deadline and you lose: Mastercard and Stripe say by default, and Visa's guide says the case may be automatically lost, even with strong evidence.
How a dispute runs
Visa Canada's three steps: the cardholder contacts their bank, your acquirer asks you for the transaction record, and you send a copy to your acquirer. Visa Canada says you could lose the sale, the goods and the handling costs. Mastercard says your evidence goes to your acquirer and the issuer then makes the final decision. Visa's general merchant guide, which is not Canada-specific, groups dispute reasons into four categories: Fraud (10), Authorization (11), Processing Errors (12) and Consumer Disputes (13).
Mastercard says each dispute still counts toward your chargeback ratio even when you win, and that merchants are generally liable in card-not-present sales. We did not read the ratio thresholds, so we state none.
If you add a card surcharge, Visa's Canadian FAQ says a disputed sale returns the purchase amount plus the surcharge, so the surcharge is lost with the sale. See the surcharge rules.
Who each fits
- Your average sale is smallA flat fee weighs most there: a CA$15.00 fee is a quarter of a CA$60.00 sale. Square's no dispute fee costs you the least on a loss.
- You sell online with a Stripe accountRespond if you think you can win more than 20% of the time on a CA$60.00 sale, since the countered fee comes back on a win.
- You take MonerisAsk in writing when the CA$80.00 handling fee applies and whether the CA$25.00 fee returns on a win. Its pricing page does not say.
What we could not read
- No readable fee: Clover Canada (its page returned no readable text) and Lightspeed Canada: Lightspeed's global payments page says $15, with no currency, and its Canadian payments page prints no chargeback text.
- Moneris. Whether its fee comes back on a win, when the handling fee applies and which currency it prints. Its pricing page does not say; a Moneris help page on chargeback fees refused our reader.
- Reserves. Square's and Stripe's terms let them hold funds after disputes; see what a merchant account is.
- Who decides in Canada. We found no Canadian regulator page on chargeback outcomes. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada's Code of Conduct complaint process covers Code breaches by your processor, not individual disputes.
- Other cards. American Express and Interac disputes run on their own rules, which we did not read.
Canada's fee disclosure box for merchant agreements has a "Chargeback fee" line, so look for it in yours. Rates and surcharges are on the Canadian card processing comparison.
Quick answers
What is a chargeback?
A chargeback, which Visa calls a dispute, is a reversal of a card payment by the cardholder's bank. Your customer disputes the charge, the bank sends the value back through the card network to your processor, and your processor takes it from you, usually with a fee.
How much is a chargeback fee in Canada?
The providers that print a fee charge CA$15.00 to CA$25.00 on a lost dispute: Helcim and Shopify CA$15.00, Moneris CA$25.00 (with a separate CA$80.00 handling fee it does not explain), Merchant-Accounts.ca CA$20.00 on both reader-rate plans, and Stripe CA$15.00 received plus CA$15.00 if you respond. Square prints no dispute fee. Moneris, Helcim and Merchant-Accounts.ca print "$" without naming the currency, so those are our reading as Canadian dollars.
How long does a chargeback take?
Stripe and Shopify usually give you 7 to 21 days to respond, and Square gives seven. Mastercard says its whole process can take up to 120 days, and Shopify says a card-company review can take up to 75 days after you submit.
Do I pay the fee if I win?
It depends on the provider. Helcim and Shopify charge nothing on a win. Stripe keeps its CA$15.00 received fee and returns the countered fee. Moneris and Merchant-Accounts.ca do not say whether their fee is returned. Mastercard says a merchant pays the chargeback fee whether or not it is liable.
Can I stop chargebacks before they happen?
Not completely. Card networks let cardholders open disputes for roughly four months, and merchants are generally liable in card-not-present sales. Stripe's pricing page lists dispute prevention tools; we did not test them.
How we know
- We read Moneris's pricing page, Stripe Canada's pricing page and its dispute docs, Helcim's pricing page, Square Canada's dispute help article, Shopify's chargeback help page, Mastercard's merchant guidance and Visa Canada's dispute page and Visa's dispute management guide for merchants (a general guide that says rules may not apply in every country).
- We read Merchant-Accounts.ca's reader-rate page for Canada, which prints a chargeback fee per occurrence and says nothing about a win. We do not link it here because that page is our referral link, which sits on the card processing page beside a disclosure.
Every fee and clock is a quote from its page, stored with its source and date, and a test checks the sums against figures worked by hand. We opened no account and disputed no payment.